• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

500 Park Ave Cafe: Fresh Sandwiches & Comfort Food That Delight

At 500 Park Ave Cafe, nestled in Mansfield, OH, food transforms into an experience. Specializing in handcrafted sandwiches, this charming café welcomes all, offering a warm, inviting atmosphere that may surprise you at first glance. Renowned for its flavorful Philly cheesesteak and delectable baklava, patrons rave about the fresh, quality ingredients and generous portions. With options for delivery and takeout, alongside inviting outdoor seating, the café caters effortlessly to every diner’s needs. Whether you’re enjoying a casual lunch or a relaxed evening out, 500 Park Ave Cafe promises a delightful culinary journey that beckons you to return.

Photos & Gallery

500 Park Ave Cafe: Reviews & Ratings

Maranda Hall
Maranda Hall

Wow the food here is AMAZING. Seriously the best burger I have had in a really long time. Everything was super fresh and tasty, even when delivered. Do not sleep on this gem Mansfield!

christy jones
christy jones

I have been watching the videos of food posted and decided it was meal time. I ordered the gyro, the kabobs with rice-green pepper-onion, the chicken with rice-green pepper-onion, and a chef salad with Turkey. The portions were extreemly generous. Everything was made fresh while I waited. During my visit I had a great conversation with the owner. I was able to choose my spice level -medium. The food traveled well on my 20 min drive home. All the food was delish and authentic. Next visit I will try the burgers. My 70 year old mom said it was the best salad with you homemade dressing.

Ryan Davis
Ryan Davis

Called in to order lunch here today. I ordered a spicy chicken sammich with fries and a soda. I ordere spicy chicken sammiches a lot for lunch. So I have a few that I constantly compare to in regards to quality. Man, I was not disappointed here today. First off, the fries. Basic, non-seasoned, slightly thick french fries fried to golden perfection. I added a little salt to taste, but other than that they were perfect. Now the sammich. The chicken breast itself was closer to Wendy's than Popeye's. Albeit it was far juicier than most Wendy's spicy chicken filets are. Also, I believe the breading on the breast itself had some seasoning/heat. But the sauce on it was similar to Popeye's sauce. Really delicious with a hint of heat. Absolutely perfect pairing with the chicken. It came with lettuce and tomato on it, which I appreciate. So this isn't a traditional spicy chicken with just pickles. Personal preference, I like it with lettuce and tomato. The veggies were fresh and smothered in the sauce. Every bite was full of flavor and juicy goodness. I would say this is one of the better spicy chicken sammies I've had. Oh, and it cost me a little over $7 total with a drink. Boom! 10/10 and will be back again. And again and again most likely. Edit: Came back for lunch today. Ordered the gyro in a pita with fries and baklava. The gyro is massive. Absolutely filled me up. And the lamb was delicious. Everything about it was great. The baklava was a little different from most other baklava I've ever had. It had a satisfying crunch and tasted great. But it could have used a bit more honey on it. But honestly, I'll get it again next time I'm there. I love baklava. Gotta stop in here. The food is brilliant.

Tammi Griffeth
Tammi Griffeth

We read about 500 PAC on Bite Club giving this little Cafe 5 stars. And they were right. Ms Vivian cooked each meal to order and each bite was packed with so much flavor! Definitely going to be our "go to" place.

Charles C Jr
Charles C Jr

My salad was very fresh & fulfilling. Very gracious with the toppings as well. 1st time coming here & definitely won't be my last.

Kristine Nichols
Kristine Nichols

Large servings and rhe perch was cooked to perfection. Huge pile of fresh made coleslaw underneath. Husband said the burger was good and wings were spot on. Definitely coming back

Nikolas Monastere
Nikolas Monastere

Hands down one of the best meals I've ever had! I ordered the club sandwich with fries. The sandwich was an absolute BRICK of food, loaded with deliciois, high quality food and sauce with bread that was toasted *just* enough to absorb the juices without falling apart. The fries were divine; crispy on the outside, tender on the inside, with no need for salt. Later I tried the philly cheesesteak and it is, hands down, the BEST cheesesteak I've ever had in my life! The owner is incredible and makes everything herself. All food is made to order, and no matter how long your wait I can assure you; it is WORTH it!

Tara P.
Tara P.

Wow! The food here is incredible. And we unfortunately devoured it before I could get any pictures. We were recommended to try here by some locals, and pulled up and were unsure if this is where we wanted to eat. Don't judge a book by its cover, we walked in and it was much more inviting. But the food, it was so good!!! We ordered a Philly cheesesteak, Ruben, mozzarella sticks, and pistachio baklava. Ms. V was kind, prepared our food to order, everything was fresh and hot, and the food was of great quality. This is the spot to try if you are in the area, we definitely plan to return.

Reek R.
Reek R.

this burger is seasoned well the cheese is melted nice and the bun is soft and the bread isn't wet from the cheese or grease. Wings are cooked all the way through nice amount of sauce and the wings are well sized Highly recommend this Càfe. This small owned Cafè is probably a place you've passed by on park ave it's worth checking out the food is reasonably priced and nice portion size.

Location

Welcome to 500 Park Ave Cafe, a hidden gem nestled at 500 Park Ave W in Mansfield, Ohio. This charming café specializes in mouthwatering sandwiches and has quickly gained a reputation as the go-to spot for satisfying meals. With utilities including delivery, takeout, and outdoor seating, this café is designed to cater to your dining needs, whether you prefer the comfort of home or the warmth of the sun.

As you step inside, you might find yourself surprised by the inviting ambiance that contrasts with the exterior. Customer Tara P. summarized it perfectly stating, "Don't judge a book by its cover." The friendly staff, led by Ms. V, ensures that each dish is prepared to order with the utmost care. The food isn’t just good; it’s a delightful experience that leaves patrons wanting to return.

  • Philly Cheesesteak: A must-try, this sandwich is celebrated for its perfect balance of flavors and hearty ingredients. The seasoned meat, fresh toppings, and melted cheese create a truly delightful combination.
  • Ruben: Another standout item on the menu, the Ruben sandwich is a testament to quality. Every bite is packed with sufficient savory goodness, accompanied by a side of crispy mozzarella sticks that complement the meal nicely.
  • Pistachio Baklava: Don’t skip dessert! This sweet treat is the perfect way to conclude your meal, offering a delightful crunch paired with rich flavors.
  • Burgers: Patrons rave about the burgers, highlighting the soft bun, well-seasoned patty, and perfect melted cheese. A culinary triumph that’s definitely worth a visit.
  • Wings: Perfectly cooked and generously coated in sauce, these wings are a crowd favorite, capturing what comfort food is all about.

Located conveniently with on-site parking, wheelchair accessibility, and bike parking, 500 Park Ave Cafe is eager to welcome all guests. And for those looking to host events, they even offer catering services.

In conclusion, if you find yourself in Mansfield, don’t miss out on 500 Park Ave Cafe. With reasonably priced dishes, generous portion sizes, and a commitment to quality, this café promises an unforgettable dining experience. Plan your visit, indulge in their offerings, and see why locals can’t stop talking about this culinary treasure.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Credit cards